Pennsylvania lets most households choose the company that generates or supplies their electricity, while the electric distribution company (EDC) — your utility — still delivers power over the poles and wires. The number that makes that choice intelligible is the Price to Compare, or PTC. If a supplier’s all-in generation price is not lower than your PTC after fees, switching usually does not save money.
This guide explains what the PTC includes, how to run the official savings math, and when a flashy offer is likely to cost you. Competitive offers are not available in every part of the state; always start with your own bill and PA Power Switch.
What the Price to Compare is — and what it is not
The Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission (PUC) describes the PTC as the price per kilowatt-hour your electric distribution company will charge for the generation portion of your service. On the commission’s bill-breakdown fact sheet, that figure is built as supply plus transmission: it is the default-service generation price, not your whole bill.
Delivery charges — the cost of the poles, wires, meter, and local service — stay with the EDC whether you shop or not. A supplier can beat the PTC and your total bill will still include those delivery charges. If you have already chosen a competitive supplier, the generation line on your bill reflects that supplier’s price, and the PTC remains the yardstick for deciding whether a new offer (or a return to default service) is better.
The Gross Receipts Tax, a Pennsylvania tax on sales of electric energy in the state, is included in the PTC. Both EDCs and electric generation suppliers (EGSs) include it in the cost of generation supply. For residential customers, PA Power Switch states that all applicable taxes are included in the price a supplier presents. Sales tax may still apply if the service is for a second home or a property you rent out.
Where to find it on your bill
Look for a line or box labeled “Price to Compare.” Utilities present it in cents per kWh. You will also need your rate schedule (PA Power Switch asks for it after you enter a ZIP code) and a realistic average of your monthly usage. Most bills include a usage graph covering about a year; use that, not a single mild-weather month, when you do the math.
The PTC itself is not permanent. Default-service rates are updated on a schedule that varies by utility. A supplier price that beats today’s PTC may not beat the next one, which is why the PUC tells shoppers to ask how long both the utility PTC and the supplier’s price are effective.
The official way to tell if you will save
The PUC’s consumer workbook uses a simple worksheet. In plain language:
- Write down your EDC’s Price to Compare, in cents per kWh.
- Write down the supplier’s generation price, also in cents per kWh, with taxes included for a residential account.
- Subtract the supplier price from the PTC. If the result is zero or negative, the offer does not save money on generation — stop there unless you are paying extra on purpose for renewable supply or another feature.
- Multiply the difference by your average monthly kWh, then divide by 100. That is the estimated monthly generation savings in dollars.
- Subtract any monthly supplier fee. The remainder is your estimated net monthly savings.
The commission’s shopping materials note that “saving just one cent per kWh could translate into more than $100 a year in savings, depending on usage.” That is an illustration, not a guarantee. At 850 kWh a month, one cent per kWh is about $8.50 a month, or roughly $102 a year, before monthly fees. At 500 kWh, the same one-cent gap is about $60 a year. Always use your own usage, and never skip the monthly fee step.
When switching does not save money
A rate that looks lower than the PTC can still be a poor deal. Watch for:
- Introductory or “teaser” prices. PA Power Switch distinguishes an introductory price — a temporary promotional rate for the first billing cycles, after which the price changes to the ongoing fixed or variable rate in the disclosure statement — from a “new customers only” plan, which is simply limited to customers who have not recently been with that supplier. Ask what the price will be after the introductory period, in writing, before you enroll.
- Variable rates without a cap. Ask whether there is a limit to how high the rate can go, how you will be notified of changes, and whether the supplier can give you up to two years of historical pricing. Pennsylvania regulations require suppliers offering a variable price to provide up to two years of historical pricing data upon request.
- Monthly fees and early cancellation penalties. A low cents-per-kWh figure plus a $10 monthly fee can erase the savings on a modest usage household. If you already have a contract, check the disclosure for an early cancellation fee before you shop. Those fees do not apply in the last 30 days of your contract, so you are free to shop in that window.
- Time-of-use plans that do not match your life. Off-peak discounts help only if you can actually shift usage — for example, charging an EV overnight. Confirm the hours with the supplier; they vary and can change on weekends or by season.
How to switch, and how to switch back
Once you choose a licensed supplier on PA Power Switch (or directly with a PUC-licensed EGS), the new supplier starts the switch. With Pennsylvania’s accelerated switching rules, you can likely change suppliers in three business days after the EDC is notified. There is no separate “switching fee” from the utility process, but your current contract may still charge an early cancellation penalty if you leave before that last-30-days window.
You can always return to your utility’s default service: contact the EDC and ask to go back. Check the current contract first. If you do not respond to contract-expiration notices, the supplier may continue to serve you on different terms and prices — sometimes a variable rate, in which case it must give advance notice of future price changes. You should receive two renewal notices; the second comes in writing by U.S. mail.
A related option in some nearby states: community solar
Shopping for a generation supplier is not the same as joining a solar project. In some states that also have retail electricity choice — including New York, Maryland, Illinois, New Jersey, Minnesota, and Maine — households can subscribe to a community solar project and receive a credit on the utility bill, usually without installing panels on the roof. Availability depends on your ZIP code, utility, and whether a project still has open subscriptions. Pennsylvania’s Price to Compare measures default generation supply; it is not a community-solar credit.
If you have questions about a supplier or a switch, the Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission can be reached at 1-800-692-7380. Licensed-supplier lists and current offers are on PA Power Switch.
Sources
- PA Power Switch and its frequently asked questions, Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission.
- PUC, Electric Bill Breakdown fact sheet (Price to Compare = supply + transmission).
- PUC, Electric Choice workbook and Taking Action by Choosing an Electric Supplier, including the savings worksheet and the “one cent per kWh” illustration.
Disclosure
This article is general information, not legal, financial, or energy-procurement advice. Plan prices, utility default rates, and contract terms change. Confirm details on the official state shopping site and in the contract before you enroll.
This website contains affiliate links. If you click an affiliate link and take an action, such as requesting a quote or enrolling in a program, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. The official state shopping sites linked in this article are government tools, not affiliate links.